Hostels vs Bed and Breakfasts in NYC: What’s Best for Travelers?
Looking for a breakdown of differences to help you decide between a hostel vs. bed and breakfast in NYC?
When you’re planning a trip to New York City, choosing the right place to stay is key. NYC has options for every type of traveler from budget-friendly hostels to cozy bed and breakfasts. But which one is right for you?
At American Dream Hostel, you’ll find clean private rooms, daily breakfast, a shared kitchen, and work kiosks. Even better? You’ll enjoy our friendly staff and the chance to meet other travelers. This is a consideration when you’re considering a hostel vs. a bed and breakfast in NYC.
1. Price Point: Budget vs. Comfort
Hostels:
Ideal for travelers watching their budget.
Shared rooms (dorm-style) cost less per night.
Great for backpackers, students, solo adventurers.
B&Bs:
Generally higher nightly rates, especially in Manhattan.
Private rooms with more amenities.
Best for couples, families, or those looking for a quieter stay.
💡 If saving money is a top priority, hostels are your go-to. If you value more privacy & homey touches, a B&B may be worth the extra cost.
2. Social Atmosphere
Hostels:
Social hubs! Expect common areas, shared kitchens, and often events or tours.
Easy to meet fellow travelers.
B&Bs:
Quieter vibe — ideal if you prefer downtime.
Some offer shared breakfasts, but less focused on group interaction.
💡 If you’re looking to make friends or travel solo, a hostel gives you more chances to connect.
3. Location, Location, Location
Hostels:
Found in popular neighborhoods like Midtown, East Village, or Brooklyn.
Often close to subways & attractions.
B&Bs:
Tend to be in quieter residential neighborhoods.
More local charm, but might be a longer commute.
💡 Want to feel like a local? A B&B may give you that cozy NYC neighborhood experience. Prefer being in the heart of the action? Look into hostels.
Enjoy a cozy place to plan your day or knock out some work details at American Dream Hostel.
4. Included Amenities
Hostels:
Free Wi-Fi, lockers, communal kitchens.
Breakfast may or may not be included.
B&Bs:
Usually include breakfast (hence the name!).
More personal touches: towels, toiletries, sometimes even baked goods or local maps.
💡 If breakfast and comfort are non-negotiable, a B&B offers a more “home away from home” vibe.
5. Length & Style of Stay
Hostels:
Great for short stays or fast-paced travel itineraries.
You’re often in & out, exploring all day.
B&Bs:
Ideal for longer or slower stays.
Comfortable if you want to settle in, relax, or work remotely.
💡 Your travel style matters. If you’re constantly out exploring, you might not need more than what a hostel offers.
6. Cleanliness & Comfort
Hostels:
Varies by location — some are spotless, others more basic.
Shared bathrooms & bunks might not be for everyone.
B&Bs:
Usually cleaner, quieter, and more personalized.
Private rooms, better bedding, and private bathrooms.
💡 If you’re a light sleeper or need your own space, a B&B could be a better fit.
Key Takeaways
Hostels = budget, community, and convenience.
Bed & Breakfasts = comfort, privacy, and charm.
Choose based on your travel style, budget, and priorities.
In NYC, both types offer great access to the city. It’s about what matters most to you.
FAQ
About Hostels vs. Bed and Breakfasts in NYC
-
Yes! Most hostels have secure key-card entries, lockers, and 24/7 staff. Look for well-reviewed spots in good neighborhoods.
-
Some do, but it varies. Check before booking. At American Dream Hostel, for example, we offer a complimentary breakfast every morning — cozy, classic, and satisfying.
-
They tend to be pricier than hostels, especially in Manhattan. However, they often include breakfast & more privacy — which can justify the cost for some travelers.
-
Not really. B&Bs are more private. If meeting other travelers is a goal, hostels are the better option.
-
Absolutely. Many NYC hostels offer private double rooms or smaller shared dorms that are perfect for couples.
-
Usually no — but some may have limited reception hours. Always check policies ahead of time.
Summary
If you're after a place to stay that’s budget-friendly, social, and centrally located, hostels are a solid choice. If you want comfort, privacy, and a slower pace, a bed and breakfast might be better.
Still undecided? The best of both worlds exists. At American Dream Hostel, we’re a cozy, family-run spot in Manhattan’s East Village. We offer clean, quiet rooms, free breakfast, & a friendly vibe that feels like home.
About American Dream Bed and Breakfast
American Dream Bed and Breakfast is a family-owned hostel located in Midtown Manhattan. For over 20 years, we’ve welcomed travelers from around the world with clean private rooms, breakfast, and a friendly atmosphere. We’re a favorite for students, backpackers, and tourists looking for an affordable stay in the heart of New York City. Every guest gets access to free Wi-Fi, a shared kitchen, and a warm shower after a day of exploring. Whether it’s your first trip to NYC or your tenth, we’ll help you feel right at home. Book your stay today!
Family-owned & traveler-loved, American Dream is a cozy hostel in Midtown Manhattan. We offer clean rooms, free breakfast, Wi-Fi, and a friendly vibe — perfect for students, backpackers & explorers.
Our bright red awning welcomes you to American Dream Bed and Breakfast.
Rest well in our clean rooms. Read our house rules here.
Enjoy a hearty, warm breakfast each morning.
